A quality improvement program for adolescents with cystic fibrosis: focus on psychosocial skills
© The Author(s). 2018
Published: 8 February 2018
The two pediatric cystic fibrosis centers (CFCs) in Paris (Robert Debré) and Nantes, France, have been developing therapeutic patient education (TPE) programs since 2006 and have been engaged in the pilot phase of the quality improvement program (QIP) named the Hospital Program to Improve Outcomes and Expertise in Cystic Fibrosis (PHARE-M) since 2011. The objective was to improve the FEV1 of the cohort of adolescents to prepare them for their optimal transition to an adult CFC.
The two CFCs formed a multidisciplinary quality team and used the analysis of causes of insufficient respiratory function taking into account the adolescents’ psychosocial factors. At the Nantes CFC, the approach was centered on adolescents’ body image and their motivation to take care of themselves by assigning specific aspects of patient follow-up to each professional in the team. At R. Debré, an individual cause-and-effect diagram identified for each patient the medical and psychosocial factors that could account for insufficient respiratory function. Personalized actions were offered to each patient.
In 2014, the median FEV1 (Forced Expiratory Volume in 1 Second) of the adolescent cohort exceeds 90% at the 2 CFCs (Nantes and R. Debré). Between 2011 and 2014 both centers improved their ranking for FEV1% in adolescents in the Registry histograms. At R. Debré, the personalized process allowed to reinforce equality of care, offering to all the opportunity to benefit from TPE sessions and coaching with an adapted physical activity teacher. The psychologist developed a specific tool to support the patient-centered process.
The link between TPE and QIP was strong at our two centers enhancing patient centered care and targeting an optimal transition to an adult program.
The prognosis of cystic fibrosis is mainly associated with respiratory status. In the current lack of curative treatment, the objective must be to maintain good respiratory function over time. During adolescence, patients are more likely to see a decrease in their FEV1, the main indicator of their respiratory status .
As in all chronic diseases, adolescents with cystic fibrosis have more or less significant difficulties in complying with treatments and finding motivation to take care of themselves . These difficulties may have repercussions on their respiratory status .
Adolescents with cystic fibrosis have generally been followed up for many years in cystic fibrosis centers (CFCs), even since birth since newborn screening has been generalized in France in 2002. They have progressively acquired a great deal of knowledge on the disease and the treatments, and are gradually gaining autonomy, both as regards their treatments and their life plans. They transition to an adult program between ages 18–20.
In 2007, the French National Authority for Health (HAS) published recommendations for therapeutic patient education (TPE) (http://www.has-sante.fr/portail/upload/docs/application/pdf/etp_-_guide_version_finale_2_pdf.pdf). The TPE definition from the World Health Organization in 1998  is: “helping patients acquire or maintain the competencies they need to manage as well as possible their lives with a chronic disease.” TPE programs require an authorization issued by the French Regional Health Agencies (ARS), renewed according to a quadrennial evaluation based on the guidelines prepared by the HAS .
The two pediatric CFCs in Paris (Robert Debré) and Nantes have developed similar therapeutic education programs allowing children and their parents to acquire and evaluate skills during individual and group sessions.
In 2009, the French Cystic Fibrosis Registry’s report by center indicated that the median FEV1 value for adolescents aged 13–17 at the two centers was below the national median value. The two CFCs participated in the pilot phase of the QIP PHARE-M  launched in France in 2011. Their common objective was the improvement of the median FEV1 value of their adolescent patients. The 2 teams decided to work on the psychosocial factors that could affect the respiratory status of these patients and on strengthening these patients’ psychosocial skills in connection with the actions already undertaken as part of their therapeutic education programs. This article seeks to assess in 2015 the effects of the actions implemented in the two CFCs during the QIP and particularly their impact on the FEV1 value in their adolescent cohorts.
the constitution of a quality team in the CFC: “lead” physician, nurse, psychologist, physiotherapist, dietician, and a patient’s parent;
the participation of the quality teams in 4 training meetings organized by the PHARE-M national team;
the analysis of the CF center functioning according to the 5Ps assessment: Purpose, Patients, Professionals, Processes, and Patterns;
the adoption of an improvement theme expressed by a goal on a patient outcome for a population of at-risk patients and a deadline to achieve it;
the identification of leverage factors and barriers to attain this goal written on a fishbone or cause and effect diagram;
the definition of PDSA cycles to implement change actions and measure their results on secondary indicators.
Experience at the Nantes CFC
Local context and method
For the physiotherapist, focus on the patient’s attentiveness to their bodily sensations, involving them in their drainage and postural development.
For the coordinating nurse, focus on the adolescent rather than their parents during the clinic visit, programming the next visit with them and supporting them in achieving their own projects at school, on vacations or in the community.
For the psychologist, assessing and reinforcing their self-esteem, helping them manage their relationships in their community and the changes inherent to adolescence. The adolescents were also asked to respond to an anxiety/depression/coping questionnaire and the CFQ-R questionnaire.
For the dietician, assessment of energy expenditure, nutrition regimens and their digestive symptoms.
For the social worker, socio-economic and cultural assessment in order to facilitate their access to sports and leisure.
For the art therapist, in connection with the psychologist, improving their self-esteem through creative activities.
For the physician, a systematic discussion with the adolescent alone, working on the management of their exacerbations, checking their vaccinations, identifying possible issues with tobacco and alcohol and talking about fertility and sexuality.
We determined indicators to be followed up throughout the year in an Excel workbook in the patient record. At the weekly multidisciplinary staff meeting, the professionals scheduled the clinic visit program for the adolescents coming next week according to the needs identified. Every month, the quality team meeting allowed to discuss the indicators and their traceability in the electronic patient record. Annually the quality team analyzed their relevance and the adjustments to be made.
Impact on the patients
Evolution of the median and mean FEV1% of the cohort of adolescents aged 15–18 at the pediatric CFC of Nantes
N = 26
N = 23
N = 23
N = 23
N = 26
The adolescents’ responses to the questionnaire on quality of life/coping/anxiety/depression showed that quality of life was good for most of them (average score of 150). Half of the patients did not have anxiety/depression (score below 7), 40% were considered to be “uncertain” (score between 8 and 10), and two were “certain” (score above 11) .
The adolescents’ satisfaction was demonstrated through an interview with professionals, or through their involvement in the illustration of the CFC bulletin with the art therapist’s support.
Impact on the team and the process of care
Participation of a parent of an adolescent
At first a mother of a 13-year-old child was involved in the program. She participated in our meetings and gave her point of view on the indicators. She stressed that she was speaking in her own name and not on behalf of the parents’ group. After a year, she wished to stop her participation and a mother of an 11-year-old adolescent replaced her, who happened to be a quality engineer. Her contribution from both the perspective of a mother and a professional is still going on.
Experience at the Paris Robert Debré CFC
Local context and method
The Paris (Robert Debré) CFC is a pediatric CFC in Île-de-France following around 170 patients. Since newborn screening was established, the Robert Debré CFC has been managing patients diagnosed with CF from the northeast area of Paris. The families are socially and culturally diverse, mirroring the territory in which the CFC operates. They come from 25 different countries, and many of them are in a difficult or even precarious socioeconomic situation.
Therapeutic patient education (TPE) has been developed at the CFC since 2005. The TPE program has been gradually formalized and strengthened, and received an authorization from the Health Regional Agency in 2011. The TPE program develops along the childhood and the adolescence ages, with skills assessment phases alternating with educational sessions. The sessions offered are most often individual sessions, but group sessions are also organized at certain ages: parents of young children (aged 1–3); children themselves near the end of elementary school and their parents.
to develop sports activities with the intervention of an APA teacher, quantify the patient’s physical activity, encourage the patient, and assess him/her regularly;
to increase bronchial drainage thanks to instrumental aids;
to strengthen self-management and psychosocial skills through their participation in the therapeutic patient education (TPE) program;
to help the patient express and fulfil a dream or a project.
The FEV1% value and the secondary objectives were the indicators followed for the patients during periodic clinic visits.
Impact on the patients
When the PHARE-M program started, 40 adolescents aged 13–17 were followed up at the CFC. Among them, 18 had an FEV1 value below 80%.
For each of them, we made an analysis in a multidisciplinary staff meeting, prepared a cause-and-effect diagram and implemented a personalized action plan. All these patients met with the psychologist for an interview with the “feelings star” tool. This psychosocial self-assessment tool (Fig. 6) highlighted certain problems and needs, especially in less-often explored areas such as sleep and body image. It also allowed care adherence difficulties to be addressed. The example of a patient’s self-assessment with the feelings star is showed in Fig. 6.
Evolution of the FEV1% of the cohort aged 13–17 (R. Debré pediatric CFC)
N = 40
N = 35
N = 36
N = 39
N = 38
For the secondary objectives, the results varied: by the end of 2013, the 18 adolescents with an FEV1 below 80% had benefited from TPE sessions; 14 out of 18 had been trained in the use of instrumental aids for respiratory physiotherapy and 15 out of 18 had made an assessment of their sports activity and coaching with an APA teacher. But only 5 out of 18 patients achieved the objective “fulfilling a dream”. The APA teacher’s intervention led to an assessment concerning patient satisfaction, implementation of advice given, and possible changes in behavior. This study showed a high satisfaction score among patients (8.1/10); a perceived benefit in terms of a decrease in dyspnea and fatigue; better attention to hydration; and an increase in sports club registrations, which went from 56 to 65%. The use of instrumental aids and the benefit perceived by the patient are still being assessed. Finally, these actions, first initiated for adolescents aged 13–17 with an FEV1 value below 80%, were then extended to this entire age range, regardless of one’s FEV1 value.
Impact on the team and the process of care
The PHARE-M was positively received by the team and built a positive team dynamic. The team’s cohesion was strengthened. This program empowered each professional and recognized their specific skills. Thanks to the program, the entire team better recognized the psychosocial impact of the disease on the adolescents. The psychologist’s and social worker’s roles within the team were particularly highlighted, with their increased involvement and participation in the multidisciplinary staff meetings. Finally, the relationship between the team and the patient was often improved, with the team gaining a more comprehensive vision of the patient and their needs, especially in the psychosocial area.
A more structured multidisciplinary analysis of the patient’s situation was implemented. The patient-centered approach, already developed within the framework of the TPE program, was generalized. New tools were developed, such as the “feelings star”. As the initial analysis showed that the adolescents were unaware of the social worker’s role as a “resource person”, a specific session was established for all patients with her, to discuss patient rights at school or at the university and the possible status of disabled worker.
The two CFCs in Paris (Robert Debré) and Nantes chose to improve the FEV1 in adolescents by strengthening their psychosocial skills through a patient-centered approach, in connection with their respective therapeutic education programs. The goals were achieved for both teams in terms of patient outcomes and satisfaction, and in terms of teams’ functioning, interdisciplinary work and development of innovative actions. In the two centers, the FEV1% stabilized at a median value of 90% for the population of adolescents after 4 years. The improvement in the national ranking of both CFCs also suggests an acceleration of their progression compared to the overall national improvement in FEV1% for this age range.
It is difficult to attribute these results exclusively to the PHARE-M, as an overall improvement was observed in the respiratory function of CF patients (cf. the annual French national registry data , (http://vaincrelamuco.org/sites/default/files/rapport_registre_2014.pdf). Furthermore, our cohorts were open, not very numerous and heterogeneous, and various individual evolutions were observed.
Other benefits induced by PHARE-M
Within the framework of the PHARE-M QIP, the participation of a quality engineer from the quality department in Nantes Hospital and the involvement of a parent were key assets for the team. The PHARE-M methodology focuses on the follow-up of indicators, in “real time” and not exclusively based on registry data issued with a lag of one or more year. Assessing the suitability of the indicators lead to readjusting them on a regular basis. Thanks to that, the quality improvement program becomes a process that continues over time . Certain difficulties were noted by the teams regarding information traceability in the patient record, the regularity of the “quality” staff meetings, and the teams’ long-term motivation. The annual Quality Improvement experience-sharing days, organized after the training year for the CFCs having participated in PHARE-M, seem essential to maintain a dynamic of continuous quality improvement.
Impact on the quality of care
Over the years, improvements in CF care have been made at our CFCs. The role of the social worker and the psychologist became more important for the adolescents. New professionals were incorporated into our teams, with their specific skills: a physical activity teacher at Robert Debré and an art therapist at Nantes. When incorporated into patient care with specific follow-up indicators, creative activities can improve adherence to the treatment thanks to the increase in adolescents’ satisfaction with the team . Among the adolescents followed up at the Nantes CFC, quality of life was most often good and anxiety scores were most often normal; this differed from the results found in the literature [13, 14].
Synergy between QIP and patient education
The physicians in charge of the PHARE-M at these two centers were also in charge of TPE programs and members of the GETHEM French national working group for the development of TPE in cystic fibrosis in France. Work and reflection on the adolescents’ FEV1 led to identify the skills to be strengthened within this population. Their self-management of care knowledge and skills seemed generally satisfactory; however, their psychosocial skills were often fragile and deserved to be strengthened before the transition to the adult program. At Nantes, this transition is structured at key times, such as discussions about transition since 15 years of age and the “Are you ready?” assessment inspired by the Canadian questionnaire (http://www.bcchildrens.ca/Cystic-Fibrosis-site/Documents/ReadinesstoTransitionquestionnaire2008.pdf), 6 months to 1 year before the transitioning process. At Robert Debré, “pre-transition educational assessment” had been used for several years between 16 and 18 years of age leading to educational sessions according to the needs identified. The two teams created a common adolescent assessment approach, based on the existing adult model . This key period for patient follow-up was the subject of a specific quality improvement program in California, United States, in which both teams found similar approaches to determine whether an adolescent is ready to transition . Moreover, some psychological needs were identified in the parents regarding empowering their adolescents, supporting them, managing emotions… It is thus essential to involve them in the transition process. Helping the parents support the adolescent, redefine their role and express their fears and hopes are important objectives in the transition process and may help them for a quiet transition to adulthood with CF .
The PHARE-M provides tools and a methodology which structures the QIP towards the optimization of the process of care. The experience of the two CFCs shows that PHARE-M relies on the teams’ culture, in this case, the educational programs for the development of the adolescents’ skills. Through the PHARE-M, the CFCs combined a systematic approach on processes and an individualized approach centered on each adolescent. This “patient-centered quality process” maximized the QIP’s effects and allowed consideration of the patient’s needs. The strong involvement of psychologists and social workers in the TPE programs and the PHARE-M QIP strongly benefited to the adolescents and their families.
To the patient organization Vaincre la Mucoviscidose and the ildys Foundation for their financial support to the roll-out of the PHARE-M program. The authors would like to thank the healthcare teams at the Nantes and Robert Debré pediatric CFCs, as well as the parents and the adolescents for their participation.
Funding was provided by the ministry of Health to the research project PREPS 12008099 (Decision PRePS Call for Project December 5th 2012) including the related publications.
Availability of data and materials
Data are available in the centers’ patient records and in the patient registry, but will not be shared publicly because it would compromise the anonymity of the patients.
About this supplement
This article has been published as part of Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases Volume 13 Supplement 1, 2018: PHARE-M: Quality Improvement Program for Cystic Fibrosis Care in France. The full contents of the supplement are available online at https://ojrd.biomedcentral.com/articles/supplements/volume-13-supplement-1.
All the authors have read and approve the final manuscript.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- Welsh L, Robertson CF, Ranganathan SC. Increased rate of lung function decline in Australian adolescents with cystic fibrosis. Pediatr Pulmonol. 2014;49(9):873–7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dziuban E. and al. Identifying barriers to treatment adherence and related attitudinal patterns in adolescents with cystic fibrosis. Pediatr Pulmonol. 2010;45(5):450–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Eakin MN. Longitudinal association between medication adherence and lung health in people with CF. J Cystic Fibros. 2011;10:258–64.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- WHO. Therapeutic Patient Education — Continuing Education Programs for Health Care Providers in the field of Chronic Disease. Report of a WHO Working group; 1998. www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/145294/E63674.pdf.
- Evaluation quadriennale d’un programme d’ETP accessible at: http://www.has-sante.fr/portail/jcms/c_1748115/fr/evaluation-quadriennale-d-un-programme-d-education-therapeutique-du-patient-une-demarche-d-auto-evaluation. Accessed 19 Nov 2017.
- Bertrand D, Introduction of a collaborative quality improvement program in the French Cystic Fibrosis network: the PHARE-M initiative, OJRD. 2017;12(2).Google Scholar
- Outil Echelle HAD accessible at: https://www.has-sante.fr/portail/upload/docs/application/pdf/2014-11/outil__echelle_had.pdf. Accessed 19 Nov 2017.
- Pfeffer PE. The psychosocial and psychiatric side of cystic fibrosis in adolescents and adults. J Cyst Fibros. 2003;2(2):61–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Alistair JA. Duff. Motivational interviewing for adherence problems in cystic fibrosis. Pediatr Pulmonol. 2010;45:211–20.Google Scholar
- French Cystic Fibrosis Registry 2013. Vaincre la Mucoviscidose, INED. http://vaincrelamuco.org/sites/default/files/french_cf_registryannual_data_report_2013.pdf.
- Quach P, Nguyen GC, Benchimol EI. Quality improvement in pediatric inflammatory bowel disease: moving forward to improve outcomes. World J Gastroenterol. 2013;19(38):6367–74.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Steinkamp G, Ulrich G. Patient satisfaction in CF oral presentation. ECFS. 2010;19:20.Google Scholar
- Quittner A. Prevalence and impact of depression in cystic fibrosis. Curr Opin Pulm Med. 2008;14(6):582–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Withers AL. Management Issues for Adolescents with Cystic Fibrosis. Pulm Med. 2012;2012:134132.Google Scholar
- Gagnayre R, Marchand C, Pinosa C, Brun MF, Billot D, Iguenane J. Approche conceptuelle d'un dispositif d'évaluation pédagogique du patient (Conceptual Review of a Pedagogical Patient Assessment System). Pédagogie Médicale. 2006;7:31–42.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Okumura M, Ong D, Dawson D, et al. Improving transition from pediatric to adult cystic fibrosis care: program implementation and evaluation. BMJ Qual Saf. 2014;23:i64–72.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- LKI T, Schwartz LA, Sawicki GS, Britto MT. Cystic fibrosis and transition to adult medical care. Pediatrics. 2010;125(3):566–73.View ArticleGoogle Scholar