Identification of two novel SALL1 mutations in chinese families with townes-brocks syndrome and literature review
Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases volume 18, Article number: 250 (2023)
Townes-Brocks syndrome is a rare autosomal dominant genetic syndrome caused by mutations in SALL1. The clinical features of Townes-Brocks syndrome are highly heterogonous. Identification of new SALL1 mutations and study of the relation between SALL1 mutations and clinical features can facilitate diagnosis of Townes-Brocks syndrome.
We collected clinical data and blood samples of the two patients and their family members for whole-exome sequencing and Sanger sequencing. Prediction analysis of the SALL1variation protein structure was achieved using Alphafold. The clinical materials and gene sequencing results were analyzed. The clinical materials and gene sequencing results were analyzed. The related literature of Townes-Brocks syndrome were searched and the genotype-renal phenotype analysis was performed combined with this two cases.
Based on the clinical features and gene sequencing results, the two patients were diagnosed as Townes-Brocks syndrome. Two novel SALL1 mutations (c.878-887del and c.1240G > T) were identified, both of which were pathogenic mutations. The correlation between genotypes and renal phenotypes in Townes-Brocks syndrome patients caused by SALL1 mutation were summarized.
This study identified two novel mutations and provided new insights into the correlation of genotypes and renal phenotypes of Townes-Brocks syndrome.
Townes-Brocks syndrome (TBS; OMIM 104,780) was first described by Townes and Brocks in 1972 as a rare autosomal dominant malformation syndrome . Till now, more than 100 cases of TBS have been reported. The incidence of TBS is 1:250,000 . The clinical features of TBS patients are highly heterogeneous, with the main clinical features being anal atresia, external ear dysplasia and thumb deformity . Other clinical features may include congenital heart defects, malformations of the renal or genitourinary system, eye abnormalities, endocrine abnormalities and growth retardation . TBS is caused by mutations in the zinc finger transcription factor SALL1 . SALL1 protein is one of the four members of the evolutionarily conserved SALL protein family that are essential for organogenesis. SALL1 protein is mainly expressed in brain, liver and kidney and highly expressed during embryonic development [5,6,7,8]. It is an important regulator in the development of the urinary system, limbs, ears, brain and liver. SALL1 mutations can cause malformation of the anus, outer ear, limbs and urogenital system by altering the protein spatial structure . Different types of SALL1 mutations have been reported in TBS patients, including nonsense mutation, frameshift mutation, gene deletion, duplication and insertion . The clinical features and severity of TBS caused by different mutations are often different. Here, we reported two patients with TBS, one with renal failure, polycystic nephropathy, external ear dysplasia, and the other one with renal failure and external ear dysplasia. The clinical and genetic characteristics of the two cases are summarized. Based on these two cases and previously reported TBS cases, we analyzed the relation between SALL1 mutations and renal phenotypes in TBS patients.
Materials and methods
The medical history and physical examination results of patients and their family members were collected. The pedigree of family was drawn. The patients were given blood routine, urine routine, liver and renal function, thyroid function and limb X-ray examination.
DNA sample collection
This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Qilu Hospital of Shandong University and conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki. Informed consent was obtained from all the patients and their families.
DNA was extracted from fasting blood samples using a genomic DNA kit according to the manufacturer’s instruction (Vazyme Fast Pure Blood DNA Isolation Mini Kit V2).
The patients’ DNA samples were sent to Fujun Gene Sequencing for whole-exome sequencing. The library was constructed using KAPA Library Preparation Kit. The target sequences were captured and enriched using the on-chip exon capture system. The high-throughput sequencing was performed on Illumina NovaSeq. The sequencing data were evaluated and qualified by Illumina Sequence Control Software (SCS).
Raw sequencing data were processed and analyzed by Illumina Pipeline version (version 1.3.4) software, filtered to remove contamination and compared with the BWA software package for clean reads. Insertion and deletion mutation were identified by GATK Indel Genotyper, and SNPS were identified by SOAP snp software. The control population databases used in the data flow analysis included the 1000 Genomes database, dbSNP database and locus specific databases. The effect of gene mutation on protein spatial structure was predicted. The conservation of mutation sites was calculated. The identified mutations were searched in the Human Gene Mutation Database (HMGD) and Clinver database. The pathogenicity of mutation was assessed using the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) guidelines .
The regions where the mutations resided in were amplified by PCR. The primers were designed using Premier 5 software. The PCR products were applied to Sanger sequencing.
The PubMed database was searched with “SALL1” and “Townes Brocks syndrome” as keywords. All literatures are published in English and freely available. All cases of Townes-Brocks syndrome with SALL1 mutation were reviewed.
Clinical features of the patients
The proband (III-1) was a 27-year-old male with chronic renal insufficiency for more than 9 years. The patient’s renal ultrasound examination performed 9 years ago revealed reduced volume in both kidneys. Blood test and urine test conducted one year ago showed that the level of serum creatinine was 459 µmol/L, hemoglobin was 119 g/L and urine protein was ++. The patient had a history of hypertension for more than one year. The patient received routinely hemodialysis and antihypertensive treatment. Physical examination revealed external ear tags (Fig. 1A, B), overlapping toes (Fig. 1D), normal X-rays of hands and feet (Fig. 1C, E), posterior thoracic process (Fig. 1F). Renal ultrasound showed reduced renal volume with multiple cysts in both kidneys. Pure tone electroaudiometry suggested conductive hearing loss. No obvious abnormalities were identified in fundus and cardiac ultrasound examination. According to the patient’s past medical history and examination, no primary or other secondary renal diseases were found. According to the composition of the patient’s family, the family pedigree was drawn (Fig. 2A). There were 13 members in three generations of this family. All the other family members were normal. The parents were not consanguineous.
The proband (III-1) presented with “chronic renal insufficiency” was a 14-year-old male. This patient had bilateral external ear dysplasia and secondary hyperparathyroidism. The level of serum creatinine was 600 µmol/L. There were no obvious abnormalities in hands and feet. His hearing was normal. The patient’s mother and maternal grandfather also had ear malformation and proteinuria. The patient’s father did not have any of the abovementioned clinical features. The family pedigree was drawn (Fig. 2B). There were 10 members in three generations of this family. Except for the proband (III-1), the patient’s mother (II-3) and maternal grandfather (I-2), all the other family members were normal. The parents were not consanguineous.
Whole-exome sequencing and Sanger sequencing
Blood samples were collected from the two patients. Whole-exome sequencing identified a frameshift mutation at SALL1 (c. 878-887del) in patient 1, which was not detected from his parents by Sanger sequencing (Fig. 3A). Patient 2 had a nonsense mutation c.1240G > T in SALL1 gene. Sanger sequencing indicated that the mutation was inherited from the patient’s mother (Fig. 3B).
The c.878-887del mutation in SALL1 of patient 1 resulted in mutation of leucine 293 to glutamine and deletion of 3 amino acids afterward in SALL1 protein. The c.1240G > T mutation identified in patient 2 resulted in an early termination of SALL1 translation after the first 413 amino acids. SALL1 mutations(c.878-887del and c.1240G > T)were not reported in HMGD and Clinver databases. Leucine 293 and Lysine are conserved in SALL1 protein across different vertebrates (Fig. 4). Structure prediction analysis of SALL1 protein showed that the c.878-887del and c.1240G > T mutations caused loss of some domains (Fig. 5). According to ACMG, the SALL1 (c. 878-887del) allele was rated as P = PVS1 + PS2 + PM2 and the SALL1 (c.1240G > T) allele was rated as P = PVS1 + PM1 + PM2. The two novel SALL1 mutations were pathogenic.
Literature review on the relation between SALL1 mutations and renal phenotypes in TBS patients
The literature of TBS patients with renal abnormalities reported from May 1984 to March 2022 were reviewed. And the SALL1 mutations and renal phenotypes were summarized (Fig. 6, Supplementary Table S1). We reviewed eighty-one affected individuals from fifty-two families, including forty-one males (50.6%), thirty-seven females (45.6%) and three (3.8%) with no gender reported. The ratio of male to female was 1.11:1. Forty-eight SALL1 mutations were reported in these eighty-one patients, including forty-nine frameshift mutations (60.5%), twenty-seven nonsense mutations (33.3%), one splicing mutation (1.2%), two gross deletions (deletion of more than 20 bp) (2.5%), and two homozygous mutation (2.5%) (Fig. 6A). 64% of them had renal structural abnormalities . 28% of the patients had serum creatinine levels above the normal range but did not meet the diagnosis of renal failure, hence, were considered having renal injury. Five patients underwent successful kidney transplants and two of them developed graft rejection [11,12,13,14]. The patients were grouped based on the location of the SALL1 mutations they carried (Fig. 6B). The SALL1 mutations and renal features of the TBS patients with kidney disease were summarized in Table 1. Phenotypic classification was based on the zinc finger domains [13, 15]. There were sixty-two patients in group A, accounted for 76.54% of all reported TBS patients with kidney disease. In group A, the average age of the TBS patients with renal failure was 23 years old and the median age was 19 years old. However, there were no cases with abnormal renal function in groups C and D. In group E, there were three patients with renal failure. One had renal failure after the age of 32, and the other two had renal failure at the age of 52. Group F contained one patient with severe renal failure caused by a splice mutation in SALL1 (c. IVS2-19T > A). Group G consisted of two families with gross deletions and all patients developed renal failure [16, 17]. Another case of SALL1 (c.3160 C > T) was autosomal recessive inheritance and the patient started dialysis treatment when she was 7 months old in Group H .
TBS is an autosomal dominant malformation syndrome caused by SALL1 mutations and approximately one in three patients have not family history with Townes-Brocks syndrome. SALL1 containing three exons and two introns locates on chromosome 16q12.1 and encodes SALL1 protein . SALL1 protein is a zinc finger transcription factor containing four highly conserved C2H2 double zinc finger domains and an alanine and glutamine rich domain . SALL1 mutations lead to TBS mainly through dominant negative effect and haploinsufficiency. Most SALL1 mutations are located in exon 2 or intron 2, especially in the 5’ end or within the first double zinc finger coding region, resulting in truncated SALL1 protein lack the lack the zinc-finger domain that mediates chromatin-DNA interactions, but retain the N-terminal domain . These truncated proteins can affect the development of heart and limb by dominant negative effect [21, 22] .Mice expressing SALL1 truncated protein are more prone to TBS phenotype, possibly due to the truncated protein interacts with other SALL family member proteins and interfere their functions . Recent studies have also shown that TBS may be a ciliary disease. The truncated SALL1 proteins can affect the normal function of primary ciliary regulatory proteins CCP110 and CEP97 and increase LUZP1 degradation. This not only leads to abnormal primary cilia morphology and growth frequency in cells, but also destroys the formation and function of cilia. Thus, some patients with SALL1 mutations have symptoms similar to ciliopathies such as polycystic kidney disease and hearing loss occur . The first patient of this study had multiple cysts in kidneys.
HGMD has collected 116 SALL1 mutations, including frameshift mutations, nonsense mutations, gross deletions and splice mutations until March 2022. Most of the mutations reported in TBS patients are frameshift mutations or nonsense mutations located in the mutational hotspot region, which is between nucleotide 764 and nucleotide 1565. This 802 bp region encodes the glutamine-rich interaction domain and the most amino terminal double zinc finger domain . Mutations in the hotspot region mainly result in truncated SALL1 protein [23,24,25]. The frameshift mutations or nonsense mutations located in the mutation hotspot region lead to classical or more severe TBS phenotypes, while the clinical features caused by insufficient haploid expression of SALL1 is relatively mild . The two novel mutations (c.878-887del and c.1240G > T) identified in this study were located in the hotspot mutation region of SALL1. Both Patient 1 and Patient 2 had external ear malformation and renal function impaired, but the renal dysfunction in patient 2 was more severe than that in patient 1.
Patient 1 carried a novel frameshift mutation (c.878-887del) in the hotspot mutation region of SALL1. This mutation resulted in a frameshift at amino acid 293 and a truncated SALL1 protein (p.Leu293Glnfs*18). This mutation is a de novo mutation. All the other members in Patient1’s family were normal. Patient 2 showed mild classic clinical symptoms of TBS. Only external ear dysplasia was observed and no dysplasia such as anal atresia and finger deformity. The patients with SALL1 mutations (c.419delC) have similar symptoms such as external ear dysplasia, finger deformity and renal function impaired . Whole-exome sequencing identified a novel nonsense mutation (c.1240G > T) in the hotspot mutation region of SALL1, resulting in premature termination after amino acid 414.
SALL1 protein is highly expressed in the embryonic kidneys and participates in renal development by regulating the expression of major renal development genes (PAX8, GDNF and FOXD1) . SALL1 mutations affect kidney structure and function through dominant negative effects and haploinsufficiency. About 40% of TBS patients have some renal abnormalities, such as renal dysplasia, polycystic kidney, peripheral bladder reflux and hypospadias . Different members in the same family may have different clinical features. In the most families, the clinical features of the offspring are more serious. The underlying mechanism is not clear [27, 28]. SALL1 protein has two key transcriptional repressor domains, consisting of the N-terminal 1–87 amino acids and 434–690 amino acids, respectively. Loss of either transcriptional repressor domain or disruption of the integrity of region 434–690 amino acids significantly reduces the transcription repression activity of SALL1 protein. The region after amino acid 690 had little effect on SALL1 activity . These may explain why renal failure in patients of group A occurred much earlier than that in group F, and the patients in groups C and D had no abnormal renal function. Therefore, the location of SALL1 mutations is correlated with the severity of the renal phenotype. The patient in group F carried c.IVS2-19T > A mutation in intron 2, leading to abnormal splicing and premature termination of SALL1 protein (1208 aa) , indicating that the pathogenic SALL1 mutations exist not only in exons, but also in introns. Group G consisted of two families with renal failure. One of them had partial fragment deletion of the single allele of SALL1 (del3384bp), which resulted in deletion of a key transcriptional repressor domain of SALL1 protein . The other had partial fragment deletion of SALL1 (del6Mb), which resulted deletion of other genes related to kidney disease . The heterozygous SALL1 mutation (c.3160 C > T) can produce a small amount of truncated protein, which may retain part of SALL1 protein function. Therefore, the carriers of SALL1 (c.3160 C > T) heterozygous mutation do not show obvious phenotypes. It is generally suggestion that TBS is autosomal dominant disease. However, the homozygous SALL1 mutation (c.3160 C > T) in 2 female siblings with renal failure, multiple congenital anomalies, central nervous system defects, and cortical blindness was reported  .
Based on the above analysis, we made the following conclusions. (1) Different members can have different clinical features in the same family. The clinical features are usually more severe in the offspring of the same family. (2) TBS patients with SALL1 mutations in the coding region for the key transcriptional repressor domain have more severe renal phenotypes. (3) Mutations affecting the 500–1156 amino acids of SALL1 protein are less likely to cause renal phenotypes in TBS patients. (4) Patients with SALL1 splicing mutations or gross deletions are prone to develop severe renal failure. (5) TBS has autosomal recessive inheritance. Homozygous mutants are more likely to have severe renal phenotypes than heterozygous mutation.
In this study, two novel SALL1 (c.878-887del and c.1240G > T) were identified in two TBS patients. These two mutations are both located in the hotspot mutations region of SALL1, which is consistent with the severe renal phenotypes. Most SALL1 mutations locate in the hotspot mutations region, and renal failure is more likely to occur in patients with these SALL1 mutations. However, more TBS patients are needed to understand the correlation between genotypes and renal phenotypes.
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in the article, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author. The two novel variants have been.
submitted to the Clinvar (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/).
- TBS :
- ACMG :
American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics
- HMGD :
Human Gene Mutation Database
- SCS :
Illumina Sequence Control Software
- SALL1 :
Sal-like protein 1
Townes P. and E.J.T.J.o.p. Brocks, Hereditary syndrome of imperforate anus with hand, foot, and ear anomalies. 1972. 81(2): p. 321–6.
Liberalesso P et al. Phenotypic and genotypic aspects of Townes-Brock syndrome: case report of patient in southern Brazil with a new SALL1 hotspot region nonsense mutation. 2017. 18(1): p. 125.
Albrecht B, Liebers M. and J.J.A.j.o.m.g.P.A. Kohlhase, atypical phenotype and intrafamilial variability associated with a novel SALL1 mutation. 2004(1): p. 102–4.
Rossetti S, et al. The position of the polycystic kidney disease 1 (PKD1) gene mutation correlates with the severity of renal disease. J Am Soc Nephrology: JASN. 2002;13(5):1230–7.
Kiefer S et al. Murine Sall1 represses transcription by recruiting a histone deacetylase complex. 2002. 277(17): p. 14869–76.
Chai L et al. Transcriptional activation of the SALL1 by the human SIX1 homeodomain during kidney development. 2006. 281(28): p. 18918–26.
Miller E et al. Implications for genotype-phenotype predictions in Townes-Brocks syndrome: case report of a novel SALL1 deletion and review of the literature 2012(3): p. 533 – 40.
de Celis J. R.J.T.I.j.o.d.b. Barrio. Regul Function Spalt Proteins Dur Anim Dev. 2009;53:1385–98.
Richards S et al. Standards and guidelines for the interpretation of sequence variants: a joint consensus recommendation of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics and the Association for Molecular Pathology. 2015. 17(5): p. 405–24.
Stenson P, et al. The human gene mutation database (HGMD): optimizing its use in a clinical diagnostic or research setting. Hum Genet. 2020;139(10):1197–207.
Chai L, et al. Transcriptional activation of the SALL1 by the human SIX1 homeodomain during kidney development. J Biol Chem. 2006;281(28):18918–26.
Botzenhart E, et al. Townes-Brocks syndrome: twenty novel SALL1 mutations in sporadic and familial cases and refinement of the SALL1 hot spot region. Hum Mutat. 2007;28(2):204–5.
Yamashita K, et al. Mouse homolog of SALL1, a causative gene for Townes-Brocks syndrome, binds to A/T-rich sequences in pericentric heterochromatin via its C-terminal zinc finger domains. Genes to Cells: Devoted to Molecular & Cellular Mechanisms. 2007;12(2):171–82.
Beaudoux O, et al. Adult diagnosis of Townes-Brocks syndrome with renal failure: two related cases and review of literature. Am J Med Genet: A. 2021;185(3):937–44.
Kohlhase J, et al. Molecular analysis of SALL1 mutations in Townes-Brocks syndrome. Am J Hum Genet. 1999;64(2):435–45.
Morisada N et al. 16q12 microdeletion syndrome in two Japanese boys 2014. 56(5): p. e75-8.
Borozdin W et al. Detection of heterozygous SALL1 deletions by quantitative real time PCR proves the contribution of a SALL1 dosage effect in the pathogenesis of Townes-Brocks syndrome. 2006. 27(2): p. 211–2.
Vodopiutz J et al. Homozygous SALL1 mutation causes a novel multiple congenital anomaly-mental retardation syndrome 2013. 162(3): p. 612-7.
Netzer C et al. SALL1, the gene mutated in Townes-Brocks syndrome, encodes a transcriptional repressor which interacts with TRF1/PIN2 and localizes to pericentromeric heterochromatin. 2001. 10(26): p. 3017–24.
Kohlhase J et al. High incidence of the R276X SALL1 mutation in sporadic but not familial Townes-Brocks syndrome and report of the first familial case. 2003. 40(11): p. e127.
Bozal-Basterra L et al. Truncated SALL1 impedes primary cilia function in Townes-Brocks Syndrome. 2018. 102(2): p. 249–65.
Kiefer S et al. SALL1 truncated protein expression in Townes-Brocks syndrome leads to ectopic expression of downstream genes. 2008. 29(9): p. 1133–40.
Botzenhart E et al. Townes-Brocks syndrome: twenty novel SALL1 mutations in sporadic and familial cases and refinement of the SALL1 hot spot region. 2007. 28(2): p. 204–5.
Faguer S et al. Nephropathy in Townes-Brocks syndrome (SALL1 mutation): imaging and pathological findings in adulthood. 2009. 24(4): p. 1341–5.
Cassandri M, et al. Zinc-finger Proteins in Health and Disease. 2017;3:17071.
Basta J et al. Sall1 balances self-renewal and differentiation of renal progenitor cells. 2014. 141(5): p. 1047–58.
Netzer C et al. Defining the heterochromatin localization and repression domains of SALL1. 2006. 1762(3): p. 386–91.
Botzenhart E et al. SALL1 mutation analysis in Townes-Brocks syndrome: twelve novel mutations and expansion of the phenotype. 2005. 26(3): p. 282.
Blanck C et al. Three novel SALL1 mutations extend the mutational spectrum in Townes-Brocks syndrome. 2000. 37(4): p. 303–7.
The authors thank all subjects for participating in this study.
This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (81770660).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study was conducted according to the guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki and approved by the Ethics Committee of Qilu Hospital of Shandong University (KYLL-202306-085). Informed consent was obtained from all the patients and their families.
Consent for publication
The consent for publication was acquired from patients or patients’ parents.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
About this article
Cite this article
Wang, Z., Sun, Z., Diao, Y. et al. Identification of two novel SALL1 mutations in chinese families with townes-brocks syndrome and literature review. Orphanet J Rare Dis 18, 250 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13023-023-02874-4
- Townes-Brocks syndrome
- Whole-exome sequencing
- Renal phenotype