An example of the utility of genomic analysis for fast and accurate clinical diagnosis of complex rare phenotypes
- Polona Le Quesne Stabej1,
- Chela James1,
- Louise Ocaka1,
- Mehmet Tekman2,
- Stephanie Grunewald3,
- Emma Clement4,
- Horia C. Stanescu2,
- Robert Kleta2,
- Deborah Morrogh5,
- Alistair Calder6,
- Hywel J. Williams†1 and
- Maria Bitner-Glindzicz†1Email author
© The Author(s). 2017
Received: 16 November 2016
Accepted: 31 January 2017
Published: 7 February 2017
We describe molecular diagnosis in a complex consanguineous family: four offspring presented with combinations of three distinctive phenotypes; non-syndromic hearing loss (NSHL), an unusual skeletal phenotype comprising multiple fractures, cranial abnormalities and diaphyseal expansion, and significant developmental delay with microcephaly. We performed Chromosomal Microarray Analysis on the offspring with either the skeletal or developmental delay phenotypes, and linkage analysis and whole exome sequencing (WES) on all four children, parents and maternal aunt.
Chromosomal microarray and FISH analysis identified a de novo unbalanced translocation as a cause of the microcephaly and severe developmental delay. WES identified a NSHL-causing splice variant in an autosomal recessive deafness gene PDZD7 which resided in a linkage region and affected three of the children. In the two children diagnosed with an unusual skeletal phenotype, WES eventually disclosed a heterozygous COL1A1 variant which affects C-propetide cleavage site of COL1. The variant was inherited from an apparently unaffected mosaic father in an autosomal dominant fashion. After the discovery of the COL1A1 variant, the skeletal phenotype was diagnosed as a high bone mass form of osteogenesis imperfecta.
Next generation sequencing offers an unbiased approach to molecular genetic diagnosis in highly heterogeneous and poorly characterised disorders and enables early diagnosis as well as detection of mosaicism.
KeywordsNext generation sequencing Autosomal recessive non-syndromic hearing loss PDZD7 Osteogenesis imperfecta Mosaicism COL1A1 C-propeptide cleavage site
Molecular genetic diagnosis is currently undergoing a considerable transformation with the implementation of next generation sequencing (NGS). The NGS techniques, currently still imperfect, are becoming more accurate as well as affordable, and innovative approaches are being developed to address NGS limitations such as detection of copy number variants (CNV) and structural rearrangements . With NGS generating whole exome (WES) and whole genome sequences (WGS), data management, variant interpretation and genetic counselling is often challenging.
Non-syndromic sensorineural hearing loss (NSHL) is characterised by a high degree of genetic heterogeneity which makes genetic diagnosis exceedingly difficult using traditional Sanger sequencing techniques. At present, 64 genes are implicated in the autosomal recessive form, 35 in autosomal dominant and 4 in the X-linked form . The majority of NSHL causing variants are rare and unique for individual families, with a few notable exceptions.
Bone fragility with fractures in infancy or early childhood has been reported in over 100 genetic disorders from skeletal dysplasias and inborn errors of metabolism to congenital insensitivity to pain . The most common genetic form of bone fragility is osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). If relying solely on clinical evaluation, the diagnosis of OI, which is phenotypically and genetically heterogeneous, might sometimes be missed either due to mild/underdeveloped phenotype at the age of evaluation or atypical presentation . Molecular genetic diagnosis is therefore instrumental for early and accurate clinical diagnosis. COL1A1 and COL1A2 genes, which are responsible for more than 90% of all OI cases, are large with over 50 exons, making genetic sequencing for OI diagnosis time consuming and expensive. While biochemical studies, connective tissue and skeletal dysplasia panels are only helpful in some cases, whole exome and genome sequencing enable efficient, unbiased screening of all known genes involved in bone fragility as well as having the potential for novel gene discovery.
Here we report on a consanguineous family segregating sensorineural hearing loss, an unusual skeletal phenotype and microcephaly with significant developmental delay. We describe detailed molecular investigation involving Chromosomal Microarray (CMA), linkage analysis and whole exome sequencing (WES), which led to molecular genetic diagnosis of all three phenotypes.
The family is a consanguineous family of Pakistani origin; parents are 1st cousins and the mother’s parents were also 1st cousins.
Non-syndromic hearing loss (NSHL) phenotype
The mother (I-2), mother’s sister (I-3), first and second child (II-1 and II-2) have moderate congenital sensorineural hearing loss. The third child (II-3) was born with severe deafness. The fourth child (II-4) passed the newborn screen as well as subsequent visual enforcement audiometry at 1 year. He has normal language development. The father has normal hearing. The mother also has four hearing impaired siblings and four siblings with normal hearing (Fig. 1). Hearing loss is non-progressive and stable. None of these adults have complained of any visual symptoms and one hearing impaired sibling has been tested and found to have a normal electroretinogram (ERG).
4th child (II-4): radiographic assessments were made between the ages of 10 days and 19 months, including a skeletal survey (Fig. 2e-g). He sustained fractures of the right humerus perinatally and left femur age 6 months. At age 11 months, multiple Wormian bones and shortening of the ulnae were apparent. Diaphyseal expansion of the ribs and short tubular bones, with abnormal trabeculation, were not apparent at birth, but these features were starting to appear aged 19 months. DEXA z-scores are not available before the age of 5.
The key shared features in this sibling pair are: bony fragility in first 2 years of life; abnormal Wormian bone pattern with late fontanelle closure; mesomelic upper limb shortening with short ulna and bowed radius; undermodelling of tubular bones, particularly ribs and hands, with abnormal trabeculation in the hands; no osteopenia.
Informed consent for the study was obtained from all participants or their parents and genetic studies were approved by the Bloomsbury National Research Ethics Service (Reference number 08/H0713/82). Genomic DNA of the proband and family members was extracted from peripheral blood by standard methods.
Developmental delay and microcephaly phenotype
The third child was born at 38 weeks with a birthweight of 2.807 kg following a normal pregnancy and delivery by forceps. She failed the newborn hearing screen and was subsequently fitted with hearing aids. During the first year of life she was diagnosed with global developmental delay and all developmental milestones were delayed. There were initial feeding and swallowing difficulties which resolved after a few months. She sat independently at 1 year. At the age of 16 months her head was on the 0.4th centile, weight was just above the 9th centile and height was just below the 0.4th centile. She learned to stand at 20 months, which was when she was last seen. She was observed to have deep-set eyes, a prominent nasal bridge, microbrachycephaly and large ears. She has a structurally normal heart, hypermetropia and a normal electroretinogram. Biochemical investigations including plasma amino acids, vacuolated lymphocytes, isoelectric focussing of transferrins, very long chain fatty acids, lactate, white cell enzymes, calcium, phosphate and parathyroid hormone levels as well as urea and electrolytes and liver function tests were all normal.
Microarrays and linkage analysis
The parents and offspring with the skeletal (1st and 4th child) or developmental delay (3rd child) phenotypes were subjected to routine Chromosomal Microarray Analysis (CMA) either by Comparative Genomic Hybridisation (CGH) using Roche Nimblegen 135 K microarray or by cytogenomic SNP microarray using Affymetrix Cytoscan 750 K as per manufacturer’s instructions. Multipoint parametric linkage studies of all seven members of the family (Fig. 1) was performed using the HumanCytoSNP-12v2-1_H Beadarray (Illumina, Inc, San Diego, CA) as per the manufacturer’s instructions as published previously . A recessive transmission model with complete penetrance and a disease allele frequency of 0.0001 was used for linkage analysis for deafness and for skeletal dysplasia initially.
Whole exome and Sanger sequencing
Whole exome capture was performed with Agilent SureSelect version 4 (Santa Clara, CA), according to manufacturer’s protocol on all seven family members. Enriched libraries were sequenced on the Illumina (San Diego, CA) HiSeq2000. Sequencing reads passing quality filters were aligned to the reference genome build GRGh37/hg19 using Burrows-Wheeler Aligner (BWA) algorithm and for variant calling we applied GATK  base quality score recalibration, indel realignment, duplicate removal, and performed SNP and INDEL discovery and genotyping using standard hard filtering parameters or variant quality score .
The variant annotation and interpretation analyses were generated through the use of Ingenuity® Variant Analysis™ software version 3.1.20140902 from Ingenuity Systems. For the recessive model, homozygous/compound heterozygous variants shared between affected individuals were retained; for a dominant model, we retained heterozygous variants in common between affected individuals. Intronic and exonic synonymous variants were filtered out; exonic and splice variants (up to seven base pairs into intron or predicted pathogenic on MaxEntScan) with a public databases (ExAC, 1000 Genomes and ESP Exomes) frequency <0.1% (NSHL phenotype) and <0.01% (skeletal phenotype) were retained. Separate filtering steps were applied for NSHL and skeletal phenotypes.
Disease causing variants (PDZD7 and COL1A1) were validated by Sanger sequencing. Primers were developed using Primer3 software (see Additional file 1 for primer sequences).
RNA isolation and PDZD7 RT-PCR
Blood samples from parents and all four children were collected into Paxgene™ RNA tubes and RNA from whole blood was extracted according to manufacturer’s protocol using the PAXgene Blood RNA System (PreAnalytiX, Hombrechtikon, CH). Synthesis of cDNA was carried out using Omniscript™ RT (Qiagen, Santa Clarita, CA) system according to supplier’s protocol. PCR primer sequences used to amplify PDZD7 exons 1–15 are listed in Additional file 2.
Chromosomal Microarray Analysis (CMA)
Copy number variants (CNV) identified by CMA were analysed with respect to gene content, presence on public databases (DECIPHER, DGV) and whether they segregated with one of the phenotypes. CMA identified monosomy 8p23 with a loss of material of approximately 10,6 Mb between 8:176,569 and 10,781,689 and partial trisomy 18 with a gain of approximately 7.9 Mb between co-ordinates 18:141,489-8,022,950, suggesting a de novo unbalanced translocation between chromosomes 8 and 18 as the cause of severe developmental delay with microcephaly in the 3rd child (II-3). More than 100 genes are either deleted or duplicated by the unbalanced translocation and are likely to contribute to the phenotype of the patient. These include three DDG2P genes on chromosome 18 (TGIF1, LAMA1, SMCHD1) and three on chromosome 8 (CLN8, MCPH1, FBOX25) [7, 8]. Deletion of this region of chromosome 8 has been reported in association with developmental delay and microcephaly. Duplication of a similar region of chromosome 18 has been described associated with developmental delay and behavioural problems. The translocation was not observed in any other family member and was thought to be responsible for the significant developmental delay and microcephaly phenotypes, but not the NSHL. No further CNVs were identified that could explain any of the clinical phenotypes.
Multipoint parametric linkage analysis showed six regions with significant linkage (logarithm of odds scores, LOD > 3.0) to the NSHL phenotype using a recessive model; i.e. on chromosomes 3, 4, 7, 10 (two regions) and 13 (Additional files 3 and 4).
Linkage analysis though failed to reveal any regions significantly linked to the skeletal phenotype (Additional file 5) using a recessive model. Despite a lack of significant LOD scores in the skeletal phenotype analysis, we looked for homozygous and compound heterozygous variants in the linkage intervals with LOD scores greater than 2 (i.e. between 2.0172 and 2.0556 on chromosomes 5, 9, 14 and 16) shared between the two sibs affected with skeletal phenotype (Additional file 5). There were no rare variants (less frequent than 1% in public databases) in the exonic or splice (up to +/−7 into an intron) regions shared between the two sibs and not shared by skeletal phenotype unaffected sibs. We also manually inspected the BAM files for potential larger deletions in these regions and failed to find any.
Whole Exome Sequence (WES) analysis
Whole exome sequence with mean 70× coverage was generated for the parents, all four children and the mother’s sister. Separate analyses were performed for the NSHL and skeletal phenotypes.
For the NSHL phenotype, only the PDZD7 NM_001195263.1:c.226 + 2_226 + 5del (hg19.chr10:g.102789746_102789749del) variant passed the genetic filter (Fig. 1). It also resided in the linkage region on chromosome 10 with a significant LOD score of 3.6 (Additional files 3 and 4). The PDZD7 c.226 + 2_226 + 5del variant is a homozygous deletion of four base pairs at the exon 2 - intron 2 junction. The deletion affects the invariant splice site and is therefore predicted to affect splicing. The PDZD7 c.226 + 2_226 + 5del was not found in any public databases (ExAC, ESP Exomes, 1000 Genomes and gnomAD) .
The 4-nucleotide deletion in PDZD7 (c.226 + 2_226 + 5delTAGG) is predicted to affect splicing as it abolishes the invariant GT splice site at the exon 2 - intron 2 junction. On the cDNA level, we confirmed the presence of a PDZD7 product spanning exons 1–2 in the family members affected with NSHL as well as unaffected members, demonstrating that this part of the transcript was expressed at detectable levels in lymphocyte RNA. However, we were not able to amplify PDZD7 exons 3–17 in individuals affected with NSHL. In the NSHL unaffected heterozygous father, and in normal controls we were able to obtain a product spanning exons 2–6, 5–8 and 13–15, but Sanger sequencing of these products revealed that in the father, only the allele not carrying the c.226 + 2_226 + 5deletion was amplified (ie. only wild-type was expressed). The distinction between the two alleles was possible due to the presence of SNPs rs148746572 residing in PDZD7 exon 6 and rs547610251 in exon 15; in the whole exome genomic sequence the father is heterozygous for both SNPs, but in the cDNA sequence he is hemizygous (Additional files 6 and 7).
Here we demonstrate the efficiency of WES in solving the underlying molecular diagnoses in a family with complex phenotypes. While conventional Chromosomal Microarray was quick to indicate an unbalanced translocation, with monosomy of 8p23 and partial trisomy of chromosome 18 as the cause of severe developmental delay and microcephaly in the 3rd child, the causes of the NSHL and uncharacterised skeletal phenotypes in the remaining siblings were more challenging. A first-generation inherited hearing loss panel with 55 deafness genes failed to establish genetic diagnosis of NSHL since PDZD7 had not been associated with NSHL and due to the unusual presentation the skeletal phenotype eluded a definite clinical diagnosis. By the time the 4th child was born, all available family members underwent linkage analysis and whole exome sequencing. As expected (based on strong history of NSHL on the mother’s side, consanguinity as well as multiple affected family members), the genetic cause of NSHL was a variant inherited in an autosomal recessive manner - a homozygous PDZD7c.226 + 2_226 + 5del at the exon 2 – intron 2 junction which involves the invariant GT splice site. PDZD7 gene was initially described as a modifier of the retinal phenotype in Usher syndrome; more recently however, it has been shown to cause autosomal recessive NSHL [10–12].
The COL1A1c.3652A > G (p.Ala1218Thr) variant, which was inherited in an autosomal dominant manner from a mosaic father, has previously been described in a mother and son with ‘gnathodiaphyseal dysplasia’ and in two siblings diagnosed as ‘osteogenesis imperfecta with increased bone mineral density’ (BMD) [13, 14]. The two sibs described in our report had no jaw lesions or late tooth eruption as described in the gnathodiaphyseal dysplasia case. The common denominators with the gnathodiaphyseal case were multiple fractures, elevated BMD and late fontanelle closure. Multiple fractures and elevated BMD were also the characteristics of OI with increased BMD described by Cundy et al. But unlike the pediatric patients in our study, the affected sibs described there also had a significant conductive hearing loss and osteosclerosis; this might be due to age-related penetrance .
Type I collagen is a triple-helical molecule composed of two alpha-1 chains and one alpha-2 chain, encoded by COL1A1 and COL1A2. After the assembly of the chains into a triple helix, the N- and C-propeptides are cleaved by proteinases. Substitutions in the COL1A1 and COL1A2 cleavage sites block the removal of the C-propeptide tails from type I procollagen and result in incorporation of a molecule with retained C-propeptide. The variant reported here is one of the four conserved C-propeptide cleavage site residues (together with Asp1219 in COL1A1, Ala1119 and Asp1120 in COL1A2) that affects the alanine at position 1218 and is expected to abolish the C-propeptide cleavage site. Interestingly, patients with COL1 cleavage site variants had different clinical presentations, but increased bone mineralisation with multiple fractures was described in most cases (see Table 2 in McInerney-Leo et al. 2015) [13–15]. After the discovery of COL1A1 c.3652A > G mosaicism in the father, the asymptomatic father was examined radiographically (age 28 years). The hands showed subtle diaphyseal expansion of the metacarpals only but no signs of old fractures. Skull sutures were indistinct, but there was no clear abnormal Wormian bone pattern. An orthopantomogram did not show sclerotic jaw lesions. The ulnae showed minor negative minus variance, within normal limits. Lumbar spine DEXA revealed significantly elevated bone mass with age-matched z-score of 3.6 indicating a sub-clinical phenotype.
In conclusion, due to clinical and genetic heterogeneity of skeletal and hearing loss disorders as well as a clinical picture in pediatric patients which is not always fully manifest at presentation or which is atypical, early diagnosis is difficult. Whole exome sequence analysis was instrumental in establishing the molecular genetic diagnosis in this family and is sensitive enough to detect mosaicism, if suspected. Although NGS platforms are still evolving and imperfect, they are invaluable at this present time as they offer simultaneous unbiased evaluation of all exonic/genomic variants and are rapidly making their way into clinical genetic diagnostics.
The authors wish to thank the family described in this report for participating in this study and their permission to publish the results. We thank Professor Phil L. Beales, Director of GOSgene and the additional members of the GOSgene Scientific Advisory Board (GE Moore, BG Gaspar, M Hubank, RH Scott, E Chanudet, E Stupka). We thank Dr Radha Narayan for hearing assessments.
GOSgene at the UCL Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health is supported by the National Institute for Health Research Biomedical Research Centre (NIHR BRC) at Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Foundation Trust (GOSH) and UCL Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health. This report is independent research by the NIHR BRC Funding Scheme. The views expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NHS, the National Institute for Health Research or the Department of Health.
Availability of data and material
COL1A1 and PDZD7 variants identified in this study have been submitted to LOVD gene specific databases. Pathogenic CNV (de novo unbalanced translocation between chromosomes 8 and 18) will be submitted to DECIPHER.
MB-G: conception of study; MB-G, HJW and RK: design of study; PLS, MB-G, AC and HJW wrote the paper; RK, DM and SG: critical analysis of the manuscript; PLS: whole exome sequence analysis, Sanger sequencing, mRNA experiments; CJ: bioinformatics analysis; LO: DNA quantification and quality control; MT, HCS and RK: linkage analysis; DM: Chromosomal Microarray Analysis; SG and EC: provided detailed clinical information; AC: radiological assessment and diagnosis of the skeletal phenotype. All the authors gave final approval of the version to be submitted.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Consent for publication
Consent to publish clinical data was obtained.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Informed consent for the study was obtained from all participants or their parents and genetic studies were approved by the Bloomsbury National Research Ethics Service (Reference number 08/H0713/82).
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- Rehm H, Hynes E, Funke B. The changing landscape of molecular diagnostic testing: implications for academic medical centers. J Pers Med. 2016;6(1):8.View ArticlePubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Heredity Hearing Loss Home Page. http://hereditaryhearingloss.org. Accessed 1 Feb 2017.
- Bronicki LM, Stevenson RE, Spranger JW. Beyond osteogenesis imperfecta: causes of fractures during infancy and childhood. Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet. 2015;169(4):314–27.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bockenhauer D, Feather S, Stanescu HC, Bandulik S, Zdebik AA, Reichold M, Tobin J, Lieberer E, Sterner C, Landoure G, Arora R, Sirimanna T, Thompson D, Cross JH, van't Hoff W, Al Masri O, Tullus K, Yeung S, Anikster Y, Klootwijk E, Hubank M, Dillon MJ, Heitzmann D, Arcos-Burgos M, Knepper MA, Dobbie A, Gahl WA, Warth R, Sheridan E, Kleta R. Epilepsy, ataxia, sensorineural deafness, tubulopathy, and KCNJ10 mutations. N Engl J Med. 2009;360(19):1960–70.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- McKenna A, Hanna M, Banks E, Sivachenko A, Cibulskis K, Kernytsky A, Garimella K, Altshuler D, Gabriel S, Daly M, DePristo MA. The genome analysis toolkit: a MapReduce framework for analyzing next-generation DNA sequencing data. Genome Res. 2010;20(9):1297–303.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- DePristo MA, Banks E, Poplin R, Garimella KV, Maguire JR, Hartl C, Philippakis AA, del Angel G, Rivas MA, Hanna M, McKenna A, Fennell TJ, Kernytsky AM, Sivachenko AY, Cibulskis K, Gabriel SB, Altshuler D, Daly MJ. A framework for variation discovery and genotyping using next-generation DNA sequencing data. Nat Genet. 2011;43(5):491–8.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Wu Y, Ji T, Wang J, Xiao J, Wang H, Li J, Gao Z, Yang Y, Cai B, Wang L, Zhou Z, Tian L, Wang X, Zhong N, Qin J, Wu X, Jiang Y. Submicroscopic subtelomeric aberrations in Chinese patients with unexplained developmental delay/mental retardation. BMC Med Genet. 2010;11:72.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Balasubramanian M, Sithambaram S, Smith K. Inherited duplication of the short arm of chromosome 18p11.32-p11.31 associated with developmental delay/intellectual disability. Clin Dysmorphol. 2016;25:19–22.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- The Genome Aggregation Database (gnomAD) at http://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/. Accessed 4 Jan 2017.
- Ebermann I, Phillips JB, Liebau MC, Koenekoop RK, Schermer B, Lopez I, Schäfer E, Roux A-F, Dafinger C, Bernd A, Zrenner E, Claustres M, Blanco B, Nürnberg G, Nürnberg P, Ruland R, Westerfield M, Benzing T, Bolz HJ. PDZD7 is a modifier of retinal disease and a contributor to digenic Usher syndrome. J Clin Invest. 2010;120(6):1812–23.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Vona B, Lechno S, Hofrichter MAH, Hopf S, Laig AK, Haaf T, Keilmann A, Zechner U, Bartsch O. Confirmation of PDZD7 as a nonsyndromic hearing loss gene. Ear Hear. 2016;37(4):e238–46.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Booth KT, Azaiez H, Kahrizi K, Simpson AC, Tollefson WTA, Sloan CM, Meyer NC, Babanejad M, Ardalani F, Arzhangi S, Schnieders MJ, Najmabadi H, Smith RJH. PDZD7 and hearing loss: more than just a modifier. Am J Med Genet A. 2015;167(12):2957–65.View ArticlePubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- McInerney-Leo AM, Duncan EL, Leo PJ, Gardiner B, Bradbury LA, Harris JE, Clark GR, Brown MA, Zankl A. COL1A1 C-propeptide cleavage site mutation causes high bone mass, bone fragility and jaw lesions: a new cause of gnathodiaphyseal dysplasia? Clin Genet. 2015;88(1):49–55.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cundy TKA, Byers PH. A novel disorder of type I collagen characterised by high bone mass, a mineralization defect and tendon calcification. Calcif Tissue. 2008;82:S1.Google Scholar
- Lindahl K, Barnes AM, Fratzl-Zelman N, Whyte MP, Hefferan TE, Makareeva E, Brusel M, Yaszemski MJ, Rubin C-J, Kindmark A, Roschger P, Klaushofer K, McAlister WH, Mumm S, Leikin S, Kessler E, Boskey AL, Ljunggren Ö, Marini JC. COL1 C-propeptide cleavage site mutations cause high bone mass osteogenesis imperfecta. Hum Mutat. 2011;32(6):598–609.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar