Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of the guidelines and recommendations

From: Review and evaluation of the methodological quality of the existing guidelines and recommendations for inherited neurometabolic disorders

Authors/titles

Year

Disorder

Authors (n)

Countries (n)

Affiliations (n)

Topics

Disorders of amino acid and other organic acid metabolism

Arnold GL [22]

2008

3-methylcrotonyl CoA carboxylase deficiency

15

2

15

Diagnosis, management

Baumgartner MR [37]

2014

Methylmalonic and propionic acidemia

25

12

21

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Frazier D [38]

2014

Maple syrup urine disease

9

1

9

Management

Haberle J [19]

2012

Urea cycle disorders

15

4

14

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Kölker S [20]

2011

Glutaric aciduria type I

19

8

15

Screening, diagnosis, management

Kölker S [39]

2007

Glutaric aciduria type I

19

10

15

Screening, diagnosis, management

NIH CDP [40]

2001

Phenylketonuria

14

1

14

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Vockley J [41]

2014

Phenylketonuria

10

1

10

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Disorders of carbohydrate metabolism

Barba-Romero MA [42]

2012

Pompe disease

13

1

13

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Cochat P [43]

2012

Primary hyperoxaluria Type 1

18

6

16

Screening, diagnosis, management

Cupler EJ [44]

2012

Pompe disease

7

1

7

Diagnosis, management

Kishnani PS [45]

2014

Glycogen storage disease type I

15

1

8

Diagnosis, management

Kishnani PS [46]

2010

Glycogen Storage Disease Type III

16

1

10

Screening, diagnosis, management

Kishnani PS [47]

2006

Pompe disease

22

3

15

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Rake JP [48]

2002

Glycogen storage disease type I

6

4

4

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Visser G [49]

2002

Glycogen Stoage Disease type I

8

5

6

Management

Winchester B [50]

2008

Pompe disease

29

17

25

Diagnosis

Disorders of vitamin and non protein cofactor metabolism and transport

BCMSC [51]

2011

Cobalamin deciciency

unclear

1

unclear

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Devalia V [52]

2014

Cobalamin and folate disorders

3

2

3

Screening, diagnosis, management

Disorders of porphyrin and haem metabolism

Stein P [53]

2013

Porphyria

5

1

5

Diagnosis, management

Disorders of mineral absorption and transport

Bacon BR [54]

2011

Hemochromatosis

5

2

5

Screening, diagnosis, management

BCMA [55]

2013

Hemochromatosis

Unclear

1

Unclear

Screening, diagnosis, management

EASL [56]

2012

Wilson Disease

8

Unclear

Unclear

Screening, diagnosis, management

Qaseem A [57]

2005

Hemochromatosis

6

1

5

Screening

Roberts EA [58]

2003

Wilson Disease

2

2

2

Diagnosis, management

Disorders of energy metabolism

Angelini [23]

2006

Fatty acid mitochondrial disorders

6

4

5

Diagnosis, management

Arnold GL [59]

2009

Very long chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency

14

2

14

Diagnosis, management

Finsterer J [60]

2009

Mitochondrial disorders

18

12

18

Diagnosis

Disorders of lysosomal and lysosomal-related organelles

Andersson [61]

2005

Gaucher disease

10

1

10

Management, follow-up

Bennett RL [62]

2002

Fabry disease

9

1

8

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Biegstraaten M [63]

2015

Fabry disease

34

15

29

Management

Charrow J [64]

2004

Gaucher disease

11

1

10

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

de Ru MH [65]

2011

Mucopolysaccharidosis type I

16

6

14

Management

Desnick RJ [66]

2003

Fabry disease

9

2

9

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Eng CM [67]

2006

Fabry disease

13

4

11

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Fahnehjelm KT [68]

2012

Mucopolysaccharidosis

7

5

5

Diagnosis, management

Giugliani R [69]

2007

Mucopolysaccharidosis VI

3

3

3

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Grabowski GA [70]

2004

Gaucher disease

11

5

10

Diagnosis, management

Kaplan P [24]

2013

Gaucher disease

11

9

11

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Kes VB [71]

2013

Fabry disease

16

1

11

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Laney DA [72]

2013

Fabry disease

9

1

9

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Langereis EJ [36]

2013

Mucopolysaccharidosis type I

17

8

15

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Muenzer J [35]

2012

Mucopolysaccharidosis type II

11

6

11

Management, follow-up

Muenzer J [73]

2009

Mucopolysaccharidosis type I

12

6

Unclear

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Ortiz A [74]

2008

Fabry disease

6

5

6

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Patterson MC [25]

2012

Niemann-Pick disease type C

6

5

6

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Peters C [75]

2003

Hematopoietic cell transplantation for IMDs

Unclear

Unclear

2

Management, follow-up

Scarpa M [34]

2011

Mucopolysaccharidosis type II

26

14

25

Screening, diagnosis, management

Solanki GA [76]

2012

Mucopolysaccharidosis type VI

13

4

13

Diagnosis, management, follow-up

Terryn W [77]

2013

Fabry disease

9

5

9

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Vellodi A [78]

2001

Gaucher disease

8

6

8

Maganement, follow-up

Vom Dahl S [79]

2006

Gaucher disease

7

4

7

Follow-up

Wang RY [80]

2011

Lysosomal storage diseases

4

1

5

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

Weinreb NJ [26]

2004

Gaucher disease

25

14

24

Diagnosis, follow-up

Wraith JE [81]

2009

Niemann-Pick disease type C

13

10

13

Screening, diagnosis, management, follow-up

  1. NIH CDP National institutes of health consensus development panel, BCMSC British Columbia medical services Commission, BCMA British Columbia medical association, EASL European association for study of liver