Skip to main content

Table 2 Overview of tasks used to assess cognitive functioning in ET AwPKU across different cognitive domains

From: A systematic review of cognitive functioning in early treated adults with phenylketonuria

Cognitive domain

Taska

Sensitivityb

Attention and processing speed

 Attentional capacity

California Verbal Learning Test (CVLT) – List A trial 1 [33]

1/1

Choice Reaction Time [11, 34]

1/2c

Conjoined Search [11]

1/1c

Detection with Distractors [11]

0/1

Digit Span Forward (WAIS-R) [33]

0/1

Feature Search [11]

1/1c

n-back (0-back and 1-back trials) [36]

1/1c

Stroop colour [11, 33]

2/2c

Stroop word [33]

0/1

Telephone Search Test (TEA) [45]

1/1

Video tracking [55]

1/1

 

9/13

 Vigilance/focus

Continuous Performance Test (CPT) – omission errors [33]

0/1

Rapid Visual Processing [11, 34]

2/2

Sustained Attention Dots (ANT) [40]

Dot Pattern Exercise (SVAT) [37]

2/2

Telephone Search Test with Counting (TEA) [45]

1/1

Test d2 [52]

1/1d

 

6/7

 Processing speed

CPT – response rate [33]

0/1

Motor Screening Test – latency [48]

0/1

Saccadic Latency [38]

1/1e

Simple Detection [11]

Simple Reaction Time (CANTAB) [34]

Finger Motor Speed Exercise (SVAT) [37]

0/3

Stockings of Cambridge – initial thinking time [48]

0/1

Trail Making Test-A [1, 2, 33, 52]

Attention Diagnostic Method [56]

2/3

WAIS-III (Processing Speed Index) [35]

1/1e

 

4/11

Executive functions

 Complex executive functions

Brixton Test [45]

0/1

Elithorn Perceptual Maze Test [49]

1/1

Object alternation learning [36]

0/1

Set Shifting Visual (ANT) [42]

1/1f

Six Elements Test [45]

0/1

Spatial Working Memory – Strategy [48]

1/1

Stockings of Cambridge [48]

1/1

Tower of Hanoi [11]

Tower of London [49]

1/2

Trail Making Test (TMT) B-A [11, 33, 35]

0/3

WAIS-III (Perceptual Organisation Index) [35]

1/1e

Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (WCST) [11, 33, 49, 56]

3/4

 

9/17

 Inhibitory control

CPT [33]

1/1

Flanker [36, 42]

1/2c

Go-nogo [44]

0/1

Set Shifting Visual (ANT) [42]

0/1

Stop Signal Task [34]

1/1

Stroop (interference) [11, 33]

0/2

Sustained Attention Dots (ANT) [40]

1/1

 

4/9

 Working memory

Corsi Block Tapping Test [11]

0/1

CVLT – perseverative error [33]

1/1

Digit Span – backward [11, 33]

2/2

Feature Integration (ANT) [40]

1/1

Letter Pattern Exercise (SVAT) [37]

0/1

Memory Search 2 Dimensional (ANT) [40]

1/1

n-back (2-back trials) [36]

1/1c

Non-word Repetition [11]

1/1

Self-Ordered Pointing test [45]

1/1

Spatial Span [34]

1/1

Spatial Working Memory [34, 48]

2/2

Visuo-Spatial Sequencing (ANT) [40]

1/1

WAIS-III (Working Memory Index) [35]

0/1

 

12/15

 Verbal fluency

Animal naming [11, 33]

2/2

Controlled Oral Word Association Test [33, 35]

1/2

Letter fluency [11, 45]

1/2

 

4/6

Language

 Basic language skills: semantic processing

Boston Naming Test [33]

Picture naming [11]

1/2

Blocked cyclic naming [47]

0/1

Emotional Prosody Discrimination test [47]

0/1

Hayling Sentence Completion Test – Part A [47]

0/1

Narrative production: Recalling the Cinderella story [47]

0/1

Non-emotional Prosody Discrimination test [47]

0/1

Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test – Revised (PPVT-R) [33]

0/1

Word reading [11]

1/1c

Word spelling [11]

0/1

 

2/10

 Complex language skills

Appreciation of Humour test [47]

0/1

Blocked cyclic naming – semantic Inference [47]

0/1

Comprehension of Inferred Meaning test [47]

1/1c

Conflicting prosody – attend to prosody test [47]

0/1

Hayling Sentence Completion Test – Part B [45, 47]

1/2

Metaphor Picture test [47]

1/1c

Naming: semantic inference [11]

0/1

Narrative production: Recalling the Cinderella story [47]

1/1

Non-word reading [11]

1/1c

Non-word spelling [11]

0/1

Phoneme deletion [11]

0/1

Similarities (WAIS-R/WASI) [11, 33]

1/2

Spoonerisms [11]

0/1

Vocabulary (WAIS-R/WASI) [11, 33]

0/2

WAIS-III (Verbal Comprehension Index) [35]

0/1

Perceptual judgement task [36]

0/1

 

6/19

Memory and learning

 Immediate recall: verbal / visual

CVLT – List A trial 5 and trials 1–5 [33]

1/1

Paired Associates Verbal Learning – trial 1–5 [11]

0/1

Paired Associates Visual Learning [11]

0/1

Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test (RAVLT) – Trial A1-A5 [11]

0/1

ROCFT – Immediate recall [49]

0/1

WMS-III [35]

0/1

 

1/6

 Delayed recall: verbal / visual

CVLT – Sort delayed recall and Long delayed recall [33]

1/1

Paired Associates Verbal Learning – delayed [11]

0/1

RAVLT – Delayed recall [11, 45] and retention [11]

0/2

ROCFT – Delayed recall [33, 45]

0/2

WMS-III [35]

0/1

 

1/7

 Recognition: verbal / visual

CVLT – Recognition memory [33]

0/1

Delayed Matching to a Sample [11]

0/1

RAVLT – Recognition [45]

0/1

ROCFT – Recognition [45]

0/1

WMS-III [35]

0/1

 

0/5

Motor skills

Digit Symbol (Substitution) Task [11, 33]

1/2

Grooved Pegboard [11, 33]

1/2

MLS [55]

1/1

Motor Screening Test – errors [48]

1/1

Pursuit (ANT) [42]

1/1f

 

5/6

Social-cognitive abilities

Face Recognition (ANT) [41]

1/1g

Faux-Pas Recognition Test [41]

1/1h

Identification of Facial Emotions (ANT) [41]

1/1g

Reading the Mind in the Eyes Task [41]

1/1h

 

4/4

Visual-spatial abilities

Block design (WAIS-R) [33]

0/1

Picture arrangement (WAIS-R) [33]

0/1

Picture completion (WAIS-R) [33]

0/1

ROCFT – with copy/initial copy [33, 45, 49, 56]

2/4

 

2/7

  1. a Number of observed impairments in task performance in ET AwPKU / frequency of us; b (−sub measure) if task relates to multiple cognitive domains); c Compared to controls, ET AwPKU differed in speed (slower), not accuracy; d Only for older (>32) ET AwPKU;
  2. e Only for off-diet ET AwPKU; f High-high ET AwPKU group worse performance than low-high PKU group (no controls included in analysis); g Effect disappeared after adding age as a covariate; h Effect disappeared after including IQ as a covariate